Corruption across EU ‘breathtaking’
European Commission says graft costs region at least 120 billion euros a year
BRUSSELS — Corruption costs Europe 120 billion euros a year, or around one percent of economic output, according to the first ever report on graft in the 28-nation European Union by the executive European Commission.
“The extent of the problem is breathtaking,” Cecilia Malmstrom, EU Commissioner for Home Affairs, wrote in Sweden’s Goeteborgs-Posten daily. .
The report published yesterday places the EU, often portrayed as one of the globe’s cleanest regions, in an unflattering light.
Among businesses, belief is widespread that the only way to succeed is through political connections and almost half of the companies doing business in Europe say corruption is a problem for them.
A rising number of EU citizens think it is getting worse, although experiences of corruption vary across the bloc. Almost all firms in Greece, Spain and Italy believe it is widespread. It is considered rare in Denmark, Finland and Sweden.
That mirrors the findings of Transparency International’s corruption perception index. It named Greece as the worst performer in the EU, sharing 80th place with China. Denmark was seen as the least corrupt.
“Corruption undermines citizens’ confidence in democratic institutions and the rule of law, it hurts the European economy and deprives states of much-needed tax revenue,” said Malmstrom.
Many EU citizens believe corruption has become worse as a result of the deep economic and financial problems in the euro zone zone brought on by the sovereign debt crisis, the Commission survey showed.
“In a time of appalling economic and financial crisis, recovering for the legal economy the money deviated by defrauders is of utmost importance; those funds are very much needed to foster growth and jobs,” said Spain’s Juan Fernando López Aguilar, who chairs the European Parliament’s Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs Committee.
Construction companies, which often tender for government contracts, are the most affected. Almost eight in 10 of those asked complained about corruption.
The cost to the European economy is estimated by the Commission at 120 billion euros annually, almost the size of the Romanian economy. Overall, 43 percent of firms see corruption as a problem.
“There are no corruption-free zones in Europe,” Malmstrom told a news conference. “We are not doing enough. And this is true for all member states.”
The study does not rank countries according to the prevalence of corrupt practices, but Malmstrom acknowledged some of the “younger democracies” in Eastern Europe face special challenges.
The report includes a breakdown of each EU member nation’s problems and success stories.
According to the EU Commission, belief that corruption is commonplace is also widespread among EU citizens. A growing number believe it has grown worse in recent years. They think Greece, Italy, Lithuania, Spain and the Czech Republic are the most corrupt.
Citizens also suspect corruption is common in business. Eight out of 10 believe that close links between business and politics lead to corruption.
“Europe’s problem is not so much with small bribes on the whole,” said Carl Dolan of Transparency International in Brussels. “It’s with the ties between the political class and industry.
“There has been a failure to regulate politicians’ conflicts of interest in dealing with business,” he said. “The rewards for favouring companies, in allocating contracts or making changes to legislation, are positions in the private sector when they have left office rather than a bribe.”
The European Commission recommended better controls and a redoubling of enforcement.
The report was published shortly after Romania’s former prime minister, Adrian Nastase, was sent to jail for four years for taking bribes. He was the first premier to be put behind bars since the collapse of Communism in Europe in 1989.
The EU has repeatedly raised concerns about a failure to tackle high-level graft in Romania and Bulgaria, the bloc’s two poorest members. They have been blocked from joining the passport-free Schengen zone over the issue since their entry.
In October 2012, former European health commissioner John Dalli was forced to quit after an associate was accused of asking for 60 million euros from a tobacco company in return for influencing EU tobacco law.
Herald with Reuters, AP